What is Happening With Bruno Fernandes and Manchester United?
Bruno Fernandes questioned Carrick’s tactics after Manchester United’s 4-1 defeat to Como. After Lisandro Martinez aired his grievances following the Atletico defeat last week, what exactly is happening at Manchester United?

Manchester United were thrashed 4-1 by Como on Wednesday, conceding four goals in Europe for the first time in more than three decades against a club playing only its third Champions League game. All hell broke loose after the final whistle.
Michael Carrick walked past his players to apologise to the travelling supporters. Bruno Fernandes told TNT that the coaching staff had decided against pressing man-to-man. Carrick then made his point clear: without players running, no system works.
This is damning for Carrick because Lisandro Martinez also called out the club after Atletico's defeat.
United's defeat has opened Pandora’s box for the club again. What exactly is happening at Old Trafford?
Four Games in 12 Days Are Exposing Carrick’s United
Carrick's initial impact on the squad and the club suggested United had finally found some stability. He took over a team without European football, had a clear week to prepare for most matches and got enough from his players to finish strongly.
This season has been different. United have been asked to play twice a week, travel across Europe and deal with injuries at the same time. Shaw, Mainoo, Martínez, Rashford, Dorgu and Heaven were all absent from training before the Como game, leaving Carrick with fewer options at exactly the point when his team needed them.
Fixture congestion and the injuries it piles up are understandable, but every other big club, including United, knows this part of the drill; this cannot be an excuse.
United have struggled in the league too, and their performances have become harder to defend. A team that looked organised last season now looks short of energy, confidence and, at times, direction.
Carrick has not found a way to make the squad cope with the demands placed on it.
United’s Expensive Squad Has Almost No European Pedigree
Como were better in almost every aspect of the game. United looked leggy and disjointed from the start, as they did against Atletico, but the bigger concern was how little experience the team has when things get tough.
Several of United's biggest investments have very little experience of this level. Cunha and Mbeumo came from Wolves and Brentford, Baleba from Brighton and Santos from Chelsea (Where he hardly played), while only a handful of the squad have spent significant time playing Champions League football. The quality shows in flashes, but European football demands more, especially when the game starts going against you.
That is a risk United accepted when they spent heavily on players who performed well domestically but had barely faced the demands of European football. They are asking players to learn those lessons while playing for Manchester United, where every poor performance is magnified and criticised to an extreme level.
Como exposed the frailties. They may have even less European experience than United, but they played the game with greater composure and looked far more comfortable when United were under pressure.
For a club trying to compete at the top of English and European football, that is a worrying place to be. United have spent the money. They now need to find out whether the players they bought can actually handle the level they were bought to reach, and what about Carrick? How does he sort this mess quickly?
Where is the Investment in the Defensive Areas?
United have mainly spent heavily on attacking players and midfielders, but their defence still looks the same as it did four years back. This despite making a few but not enough, defensive reinforcements.
Cunha and Mbeumo were outstanding last season, yet the step from being important players at Wolves and Brentford to carrying Manchester United is considerable. Baleba and Santos have also arrived with big expectations, while Mainoo's latest injury has removed one of the players who gave the midfield some balance.
Behind them, too much still depends on players who have been part of United's problems for years. Maguire, Martínez, Shaw and Dalot remain central to the defence, while the newer additions have yet to dislodge the old, rusted guard, and that tells you everything about their current situation.
Arsenal built their title-winning side around a defence they trusted and have continued strengthening it. United have spent elsewhere and still look vulnerable at the back. The old saying about defence winning titles may be tired, but United are providing a pretty good argument for it.
Bruno Fernandes Has Put Carrick in the Firing Line
What Bruno did after the game was inexcusable, as he threw his manager under the bus while also revealing he thought his manager was a novice.
Bruno told TNT that the coaching staff decided not to press man-to-man. When asked whether the tactics were wrong, he said the manager and staff should decide.
That is not something a captain should be saying immediately after a defeat like this. Bruno may have been frustrated, and he may even have had a point, but publicly distancing himself from the manager only makes a bad situation worse.
Players are expected to protect their manager in front of the cameras and settle their disagreements inside the dressing room. Mohamed Salah's comments after Liverpool's draw at Leeds showed how quickly that line can blur, with his public frustration creating another problem for an already struggling team.
Bruno is too important to United for this to become a sideshow. He is the captain, the squad's most influential player, and one of the few who has consistently produced for the club. He should be demanding more from his teammates, but he also has to understand that throwing the coaching staff into the spotlight after a defeat leaves everyone exposed.
Carrick's response was equally revealing. His argument was simple: tactics don't matter if the players aren't prepared to run forward and back. He was right, but the fact that the manager and captain felt the need to make their disagreement public shows how badly things have deteriorated.
Neither comes out of this well.
Manchester United have another crisis to solve, and this one is bigger than just a “bad night” in Europe. Michael Carrick has to find a way to make the team competitive twice a week; the club needs to revisit its recruitment, and the captain needs to decide whether he is helping Carrick solve the problem or making it harder.
For the latest articles, transfer stories, and fan mood, visit Fanscanr.
Track 24/7 Supporter Sentiment Across Every Premier League Club
Explore Fan Mood Index (FMI), Delusion Score, Terrace Banter, and AI match predictions updated round-the-clock from real supporters.


