LIVE TRANSFERS
arrow_backBack to All Articles
visibility72 views•schedule8 min read

Why Manchester United Sacked Michael Carrick and Crystal Palace Dismissed Pierre Sage

format_quote

Carrick and Sage have paid the price for poor starts, but are Manchester United and Crystal Palace looking beyond the dugout to find the real problems?

FS
Aamir Bakshi · FanScanrverified
Published Nov 13, 2026 • FanScanr Editorial Desk
𝕏in
Why Manchester United Sacked Michael Carrick and Crystal Palace Dismissed Pierre Sage

Manchester United and Crystal Palace have endured starts to the season that put their managers firmly in the firing line. With several other Premier League sides struggling for results, the growing list of candidates in the managerial sack race has finally claimed its first two casualties. United have sacked Michael Carrick, while Palace have dismissed Pierre Sage.

The two decisions arrived on the same day, but the circumstances behind them were quite different. Carrick had been rewarded with the permanent job after an impressive interim spell, only to see that progress unravel within months. 

Sage, meanwhile, was brought in to continue Oliver Glasner's stellar work but never managed to get Palace moving in the right direction.

Both managers have paid for poor results. But the stories of both the clubs and their respective managers tell a different story. 

Michael Carrick: From THE answer to another United casualty

When Manchester United appointed Carrick as interim manager in January, the club needed someone to steady a season that had drifted badly under Ruben Amorim. Carrick did considerably more than that.

United won 12 of their remaining 17 league matches, climbed to third and secured a return to the Champions League. He restored Bruno Fernandes to a more influential attacking role, moved away from Amorim's back-three system and gave the team a clearer identity. 

Fernandes' creative output improved significantly, and his contribution became a defining feature of United's revival.

The decision to make Carrick permanent in May was therefore understandable. He had lifted the mood around Old Trafford, delivered results and appeared to have earned the opportunity to build something of his own.

The problem was that the foundations of that revival proved far less secure than the club had hoped.

United's first ten league matches of the new campaign produced just one victory. The 4-4 draw against Aston Villa was the latest example of a side that could score but could not control a game or protect a lead. The club had slipped to 18th, and the performances offered little evidence that Carrick had a reliable solution.

There were tactical questions, too. The pressing lacked consistency, the team struggled to impose itself for sustained periods, and the balance between attack and defence remained a problem. Bruno Fernandes publicly questioned the pressing approach after the defeat to Como, while Lisandro Martínez had already voiced concerns about recruitment and the club's hierarchy following the Atletico Madrid defeat.

Carrick insisted there was no split in the dressing room, but the public comments suggested that frustration was spreading beyond the manager's office. 

United spent heavily before the season, with much of their investment directed towards midfield. Youri Tielemans, Andrey Santos and Carlos Baleba were brought in, although Baleba arrived carrying an injury. Yet the squad still looked short in important areas. Defensive depth remained a concern, while the lack of a dependable centre-forward became more glaring when Benjamin Šeško struggled with injury.

The demands of European football exposed those weaknesses further. United had spent years trying to rebuild through a succession of managers and recruitment strategies. Looks like they will be going through the same process again.

Carrick has lost his job because the results were unacceptable. There is a bigger elephant in the room, though: will the Manchester United board ever understand why no manager has been able to turn this big ship around since Alex Ferguson? 

Pierre Sage: A failed transition at Crystal Palace

Sage arrived at Crystal Palace in June with a difficult assignment. Oliver Glasner had delivered the club's Conference League triumph and left behind a side with a clear identity and growing expectations. Replacing him was always going to be some task.

Palace needed a manager who could preserve that momentum while adapting the squad to a new approach. Instead, Sage's spell lasted just five months and, in total,16 matches.

The results were poor, but the defensive collapse was particularly damaging. Palace conceded 24 league goals, the worst record in the division, and struggled to find any consistency at the back. A 5-0 defeat to Brighton was a low point, followed by another damaging run of defeats that left the club at the bottom of the table.

Sage must take responsibility for what happened on the pitch. Palace looked vulnerable at set pieces, struggled to defend their own box and often appeared short of answers when opponents put them under pressure. Those are issues a manager is expected to address, regardless of what has happened in the transfer market.

However, the squad he inherited and the recruitment carried out around him deserve serious scrutiny.

Palace had already lost Marc Guéhi to Manchester City in January, before Maxence Lacroix departed for Chelsea in the summer. Replacing two important defenders was always going to be a priority. The club brought in Axel Disasi on loan, signed the young Honest Ahanor on loan and added Takehiro Tomiyasu, whose injury record made him a risk. These were not like-for-like replacements for the players who had left.

Sage also failed to land some of his preferred targets, including winger Malick Fofana, who joined Sunderland. The club's recruitment had become a source of frustration, particularly after sporting director Dougie Freedman left in 2025. His departure was followed by changes in the recruitment structure, with Matt Hobbs taking over, and questions have since been raised about the direction of the club's transfer strategy.

There were also reports of tension between Sage and chairman Steve Parish. The manager was said to be unhappy with the failure to bring in the players he wanted, while Parish reportedly had concerns about Sage's handling of young defender Jaydee Canvot and a substitution involving Adam Wharton.

The situation surrounding Ismaïla Sarr raises another question about Palace's priorities. Liverpool reportedly made an offer of around £50 million for the winger in the summer, but Palace rejected it, unwilling to lose an important player without securing a replacement.

Keeping Sarr was understandable. He offered pace, directness and a threat that Palace could ill afford to lose. But with major gaps elsewhere in the squad, it is fair to ask whether that money could have been put to better use. Selling a valuable asset and reinvesting in the defence might have addressed a more pressing weakness, provided the club could have found suitable replacements.

That is not to suggest the sale would automatically have fixed Palace's problems. Nor does it make Sage blameless. But a manager cannot be expected to deliver the same defensive standards after losing key players without being given adequate replacements.

Palace's problems were visible before Sage arrived. His failure to arrest the decline made his position untenable, but the club's recruitment and planning helped create the conditions in which he struggled.

Two sackings, two different problems

Manchester United and Crystal Palace have reached the same conclusion about their managers, but the clubs' wider problems are not identical.

At United, Carrick was appointed after showing that he could get a response from a struggling squad. The club then backed him with a permanent contract, but the new season exposed the team's limitations and the fragility of the progress he made. United have changed managers repeatedly without fixing the recruitment and squad-building problems that have followed them from one regime to the next.

Palace's situation is more closely tied to a failed transition. Glasner left after delivering a major achievement, but the club did not adequately prepare for the departures of key defenders or give his successor the tools to maintain the team's standards. Sage struggled to impose his ideas, but the club's decisions left him with a squad that had significant gaps.

There is a common thread, though. Both clubs have made decisions that suggest they expected the manager to carry more responsibility than the wider structure was prepared to accept.

A manager is always the most visible figure when results collapse. He is also the easiest person to remove. But changing the person in the dugout is only a solution if the problems are actually coming from there.

What happens next?

United appear to have moved quickly towards a replacement, with Mauricio Pochettino reportedly agreeing in principle to take over. His experience and reputation make him an obvious candidate for a club looking for a fresh start, but he will inherit many of the same questions that have troubled Carrick.

Palace have a similarly urgent decision to make. Thomas Frank has emerged as a leading candidate, having previously spoken to the club during the summer. Whoever takes over will need to organise a defence that has been leaking goals and restore some confidence to a side that has lost its direction.

But Palace cannot treat the next appointment as a clean slate. The club must also address the weaknesses in its recruitment process and decide how it intends to replace the players it has lost. 

The sack race has begun

Carrick and Sage are the first two high-profile managerial casualties of a season that has already put several clubs under pressure. Their dismissals may bring short-term relief, but neither Manchester United nor Crystal Palace can afford to mistake a change of manager for a complete solution.

Both managers are now out of work. The people responsible for building their squads and setting their clubs' direction remain in place. They should not escape the questions that come with that. Time will tell which club has learnt from their recent mistakes. 

For the latest articles, transfer stories, and fan mood, visit FanScanr.



Enjoyed this analysis?
boltLive Fan Mood Intelligence

Track 24/7 Supporter Sentiment Across Every Premier League Club

Explore Fan Mood Index (FMI), Delusion Score, Terrace Banter, and AI match predictions updated round-the-clock from real supporters.