LIVE TRANSFERS
arrow_backBack to All Articles
visibility84 views•schedule6 min read

Sevilla Made Emery a Cup King; Aston Villa Could Be Next

format_quote

Aston Villa’s Premier League start has been poor, but Unai Emery’s side has already shown a very different level in the cup competitions. With wins over Club Brugge and Coventry, and Emery’s remarkable record in knockout football, Villa could have found the perfect setting to rebuild their season.

FS
Aamir Bakshi · FanScanrverified
Published Sep 17, 2026 • FanScanr Editorial Desk
𝕏in
Sevilla Made Emery a Cup King; Aston Villa Could Be Next

Aston Villa’s Premier League start has been difficult, but there is already another side to Unai Emery’s team. Villa are still without a league win after four games, with one draw and three defeats, yet they have won at Club Brugge in the Champions League and followed it with a 3-1 Carabao Cup victory at Coventry.

The contrast is interesting because Villa have changed so much over the summer. Morgan Rogers and Ollie Watkins are gone, several other regulars have left, and Emery has brought in a group of new players who still need time to settle. The league has exposed those changes quickly. The cup competitions are giving Emery more time to work with them.

The League Has Not Given Villa Time To Settle

Villa have one point from their opening four league games and have scored only once. Brighton beat them 4-0, Arsenal won 1-0 at Villa Park, Hull held them to a goalless draw, and Nottingham Forest won 2-1 last weekend.

The squad has been rebuilt in a single window. Watkins, Villa’s record Premier League goalscorer with 91 goals, joined Al Hilal for around £50m, while Rogers left for Chelsea in a deal reported at around £117m. Villa also lost Emi Martínez, Ezri Konsa, Youri Tielemans and Lucas Digne during a major summer reshuffle.

Replacing the numbers is only part of the problem. Emery also has to build new relationships across the pitch, introduce several new players to the Premier League and find a reliable attacking structure without two of the players who carried much of Villa’s threat last season.

The early results are poor, but the circumstances haven’t helped. Villa finished fourth last season and won the Europa League, so there is plenty of evidence that Emery can build another successful side. The question is how quickly he can get this one functioning.

Cup Football Is Giving Emery Something To Work With

The Champions League and Carabao Cup have already offered Emery a different kind of football to manage.

Villa went to Club Brugge and came away with a 3-2 win in their opening Champions League league-phase game. They fell behind, recovered and left Belgium with three points. Eight days later, Emery rotated his side at Coventry and Villa won 3-1, with Tammy Abraham scoring twice and Ross Barkley adding the third.

Those games give Emery something the Premier League currently does not: RESULTS.

The league requires Villa to repeat performances every week against opponents who know what is coming. Cup football gives Emery a clearer opponent to prepare for and more freedom to adjust his team around a specific problem.

Emery has spent much of his career thriving in that environment. He has now won the Europa League five times, with Sevilla, Villarreal and Villa. Aston Villa’s route to the trophy last season followed a run that included Lille, Bologna and Nottingham Forest before the 3-0 final win over Freiburg. 

The results showed how well-drilled Emery’s sides are, and every round tested them tactically, physically, and mentally, yet they came through because Unai Emery has a particular nous for cup competitions.

Emery Has Built A Career On Knockout Football

Emery’s name is closely associated with European competition for a reason. His five Europa League titles are unprecedented, while his Villa side also reached the Champions League quarter-finals in 2024/25.

His methods suit knockout football. Emery spends enormous time preparing for opponents, identifying weaknesses and working on specific situations that may decide a single match. UEFA’s analysis of Villa’s Europa League final win over Freiburg highlighted how carefully Emery prepared his side to deal with Freiburg’s man-to-man defending and how Villa used different build-up patterns to create space.

The same approach can be seen in the bigger picture of his career. His teams do not need to dominate an entire season to succeed in a cup. They need to be right for the next opponent.

Villa have already shown what that can look like. Club Brugge were beaten away from home, and Coventry were dealt with professionally despite Villa making changes. The fourth-round Carabao Cup tie against Bournemouth gives Emery another knockout game before the Champions League resumes against Fenerbahçe in October.

The Rafa Benítez of the Modern Era? 

There is a similar thread in Rafael Benítez’s Liverpool career.

Benítez arrived at Liverpool in 2004 and won the Champions League in his first season despite finishing fifth in the Premier League. He then won the FA Cup the following year, reached another Champions League final in 2007 and eventually took Liverpool to second place in the Premier League with 86 points in 2008/09.

Liverpool were never a one-competition team under Benítez, but his European record showed how effective his detailed preparation could be when the task focused on one opponent.

The famous 2005 Champions League run is the clearest example. Liverpool had to beat Bayer Leverkusen, Juventus and Chelsea before the final against Milan, with each tie requiring a different tactical plan. They then recovered from 3-0 down at half-time in Istanbul to win the trophy on penalties.

Emery operates in a similar tactical world. He wants to know exactly what the opposition will do and how his team can hurt them. A cup tie gives him the perfect setting for that level of preparation.

Villa Have A Second Route Into The Season

Villa still need to improve in the Premier League. One point from four games is a problem, and Emery will know the team cannot rely on cup results to cover it indefinitely.

The cup competitions can, however, help him get there. They can help the team find a rhythm, and everyone knows a win is a win.

Winning creates a different atmosphere around a new squad. New signings get meaningful minutes, players fighting for places get opportunities, and Emery can test systems against different opponents without waiting weeks for another chance.

Last season showed how quickly Villa can change once the pieces start fitting. They eventually finished fourth in the Premier League and won the Europa League, ending a 44-year wait for a European trophy.

The current Villa side is nowhere near that level yet. The league form makes that clear. But the wins at Club Brugge and Coventry have provided something the opening four league games did not: momentum.

Emery has spent his career proving that he knows how to handle cup football. Villa may need his best qualities there while the rest of the team catches up.

For now, the league table tells one story about Aston Villa. The cups are telling another. And if Emery can keep winning the games where his tactical preparation has the biggest influence, Villa’s season could look very different by the time the new team has settled.

For more transfer stories, football articles and the latest news, visit FanScanr. 


Enjoyed this analysis?
boltLive Fan Mood Intelligence

Track 24/7 Supporter Sentiment Across Every Premier League Club

Explore Fan Mood Index (FMI), Delusion Score, Terrace Banter, and AI match predictions updated round-the-clock from real supporters.

Sevilla Made Emery a Cup King: Aston Villa Could Be Next | FanScanr AI