Arsenal’s Fleetwood Humiliation and League Cup’s Greatest Cupsets
Arsenal’s shock defeat to Fleetwood is the latest reminder that the League Cup has a habit of bringing football’s giants crashing down to earth. From Liverpool and Manchester United to Tottenham and Arsenal themselves, these are the cupsets that left big clubs red-faced.

Arsenal, the Premier League champions, travelled to a 5,300-capacity ground on the Lancashire coast on Tuesday night and lost to a fourth-tier side sitting 84 places below them.
Fleetwood Town held their nerve in the shootout, Jay Lynch saved Bruno Guimarães’ penalty and Conor Haughey finished the job. It was one of the League Cup’s great shocks, but football’s giants have been embarrassed by minnows before.
From Liverpool’s troubled years under Roy Hodgson to Manchester United’s expensive failures, the competition has long made big clubs look small. These are the nights they would rather forget.
Liverpool 2-2 Northampton (Northampton won 4-2 on penalties), September 2010
Liverpool arrived at Anfield in turmoil. Roy Hodgson was winless in the league, the club’s American owners were fighting to keep control, and Fenway Sports Group’s takeover was only weeks away. Just 22,577 turned up to watch a League Two side take on one of England’s biggest clubs.
Hodgson picked a weakened side, but Milan Jovanović put Liverpool ahead after nine minutes. Billy McKay equalised, Michael Jacobs put Northampton ahead in extra time, and David N’Gog dragged Liverpool level in the 116th minute.
The shootout finished the job: N’Gog was denied, Nathan Eccleston hit the crossbar, and Abdul Osman converted Northampton’s fifth penalty in front of the Kop.
Northampton had won at Anfield. Liverpool’s season was already unravelling, and Hodgson would leave by mutual consent in January. Kenny Dalglish eventually guided the club to sixth, but the defeat remained a grim snapshot of a giant that had lost its footing.
Bradford City 1-1 Arsenal (Bradford won 3-2 on penalties), December 2012
Arsène Wenger had spent years using the League Cup to blood youngsters. This time, with Arsenal seven years without a trophy, he sent out a side packed with established internationals. They still could not get past League Two Bradford at a freezing Valley Parade.

Garry Thompson volleyed Bradford ahead after Gary Jones’ free-kick caused problems in the Arsenal box. Matt Duke kept making saves, and Arsenal needed Thomas Vermaelen’s 88th-minute header to force extra time.
In the penalty shootout, Duke denied Santi Cazorla, Marouane Chamakh hit the post, and Vermaelen struck the upright.
Bradford had won their ninth consecutive shootout. They went on to knock out Aston Villa in the semi-final before losing 5-0 to Swansea in the final, while Arsenal’s trophy drought continued until the 2014 FA Cup.
Wenger called it a traditional English cup tie. Bradford had just exposed a familiar Arsene Wenger weakness at the time: all that possession and pretty play, but no end result.
MK Dons 4-0 Manchester United, August 2014
Louis van Gaal had been in charge for only weeks when Manchester United travelled to Stadium MK. The club announced Ángel Di María’s British-record £59.7 million transfer shortly before kick-off, but the new signing was not there to rescue them.
Van Gaal made ten changes from the side that had drawn with Sunderland, leaving David de Gea as the only player to keep his place.
MK Dons, a League One club founded in 2004, tore into them. Will Grigg scored twice after capitalising on defensive mistakes, before Arsenal loanee Benik Afobe came off the bench to add two more.

The home crowd sang that Van Gaal would be sacked in the morning. Dele Alli, still only 18, was among those making United look second-rate.
Van Gaal asked supporters to believe in his philosophy, and United eventually finished fourth. But a club that had just spent a fortune on Di María and other stars was dismantled by a third-tier side. The 4-0 defeat became an early warning that United’s problems ran much deeper than their manager’s team selection.
Colchester United 0-0 Tottenham (Colchester won 4-3 on penalties), September 2019
Tottenham were already wobbling when they travelled to Colchester. They had lost at Leicester three days earlier, Mauricio Pochettino was under pressure, and Harry Kane was left out. Even with Dele Alli, Lucas Moura and Christian Eriksen involved, Spurs could not find a way through a League Two defence.
Colchester had already beaten Crystal Palace on penalties and were happy to make Tottenham work for every opening. Spurs had more than 70% possession and 19 shots, yet nothing seemed effective.
In the penalty shootout, Eriksen, introduced as a substitute, saw his penalty saved; Lucas hit the crossbar, and Tom Lapslie converted the decisive kick.

The result was bad enough. The reaction to Eriksen, whose future was already uncertain, made the night even more embarrassing, as Spurs fans didn't like the effort.
Pochettino was sacked eight weeks later with Spurs 14th, and Eriksen left in January. A disaster was waiting to happen after Spurs lost the CL final to Liverpool the previous season; Colchester was the fixture where it all started to implode.
Crawley Town 2-0 Fulham, August 2022
Fulham arrived at Crawley in good spirits, newly promoted and fresh off a 3-2 win over Brentford. Marco Silva made ten changes, giving League Two Crawley an opening they seized.
The hosts had taken just one point from their first five games under Kevin Betsy and were sitting 23rd in the division.
Tom Nichols put Crawley ahead in the 16th minute. Liverpool loanee James Balagizi doubled the lead four minutes into the second half, as Fulham remained clueless. The final whistle brought a pitch invasion, later condemned by the EFL and investigated by the FA.

For Crawley, it was a night to remember. Fulham recovered well enough to finish tenth in the Premier League, so the defeat did not define their season.
Grimsby Town 2-2 Manchester United (Grimsby won 12-11 on penalties), August 2025
A decade after MK Dons, United were back in the League Cup’s second round, without European football and with one point from their opening two league games.
Grimsby, meanwhile, were unbeaten in six at Blundell Park. The gap in status was enormous. The gap on the pitch was not.
Charles Vernam scored after 22 minutes, and Tyrell Warren added a second from a corner eight minutes later. Both goals followed errors from André Onana. United improved after the break, with Bryan Mbeumo pulling one back before Harry Maguire headed in an 89th-minute equaliser.

The shootout went to 13 rounds. Both goalkeepers scored, but Mbeumo struck the crossbar with his second attempt, sending the home crowd into delirium. Ruben Amorim apologised to United’s supporters and insisted the problem was “not the goalkeeper, it’s everything”. Amorim lost his job in January.
Grimsby’s win was no fluke; United had been hanging by a thread all night. They conceded two goals, needed a late equaliser, and still couldn't finish the job. For a club of United’s stature, that was a humiliating way to exit.
Fleetwood Town 1-1 Arsenal (Fleetwood won 5-3 on penalties), October 2026
This time, Arsenal had little of the crisis that surrounded some of the clubs on this list. Arsenal were Premier League champions, had reached the Champions League final in May and arrived at Highbury Stadium expecting to progress. The ground shares its name with Arsenal’s old home, but the similarities ended there.
Fleetwood struck first when Aaron Loupalo-Bi drove past teenage centre-back Marli Salmon after 21 minutes. Arsenal dominated possession, and Mikel Arteta introduced Martin Ødegaard at half-time.
Viktor Gyökeres equalised five minutes later, but Arsenal could not find a winner. Kai Havertz missed a chance to settle the tie, and Max Dowman was sent off with five minutes remaining.

The shootout gave Fleetwood their moment. They converted their penalties, Lynch saved Guimarães’ effort, and Haughey sealed the win.
Arteta called it “a really sad day” for Arsenal, who became the first reigning Premier League champions to lose a League Cup tie to a fourth-tier side. It was also their second defeat of this kind, following Bradford in 2012.
For Fleetwood, the result will go down as one of their greatest achievements. For Arsenal, it is a reminder that reputation buys you nothing once the whistle blows. They arrived as champions and left with their tails between their legs, as they discovered the League Cup respects no status.
For the latest articles, transfer stories, and fan mood, visit Fanscanr.
Track 24/7 Supporter Sentiment Across Every Premier League Club
Explore Fan Mood Index (FMI), Delusion Score, Terrace Banter, and AI match predictions updated round-the-clock from real supporters.


